DISPUTED

The FreshStart Gym File · Case AA-2026-0003 · Public Record

Cancellations must be submitted in person during staffed hours. That's our policy.

— Front Desk, in writing, May 14, 2025

They charged me $360 on May 10, 2026

Every quote on this page is theirs.

Key figures

Monthly dues$30.00
Charged after cancel$360.00
Months billed12
StateNY
02

The short version

I tried to cancel my FreshStart Gym membership in writing. They kept charging me $30/month for a year because cancellations 'must be submitted in person during staffed hours' — which are 10am-2pm weekdays.

04

Timeline

May 10, 2025Requested cancellation via email
Jun 10, 2025Still charged $30
May 10, 202612 months of charges, $360 total
Jun 1, 2026Filed this case file
05

The ledger of dollars

Monthly dues$30.00
Charged after cancel (12 mo)$360.00
Refunded$0.00
06

The explanations

The reasons the company gave, in their words.

  1. Cancellations must be submitted in person during staffed hours.
  2. That's our policy.
  3. Have you tried restarting it?
  4. Your call is important to us.
  5. Let me transfer you.
07

Escalation ladder

Emailed cancellation

Front Desk — Must cancel in person

Called member services

Rep — Transferred, then disconnected

Sent certified letter

Corporate — No response

08

What I'm asking for

A refund of $360 for charges after my cancellation request and written confirmation of cancellation.

09

Action guide

Letter template

10

Petition · Me too

Angry Advisors2people added their name to this file.

FreshStart made me come in person to cancel. Took three visits.

— Jordan K. · Oct 4, 2026

They kept billing me for 6 months after I moved out of state.

— Anonymous · Oct 4, 2026

11

Case update signup

By checking the boxes below, you agree to receive communications from GAIN Power and its projects. Checking a box is optional and is not required to register.

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Collective affidavit

Did this happen to you too?

Individually we're support tickets. Together we're a pattern. Add your story above (Me too) — every signature strengthens the file.

File your own case
12

Right of reply

Representing FreshStart Gym? You may submit a response. Approved replies are published here verbatim, unedited.

Angry Advisors is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. This page is a user-submitted public record; submissions require a truth attestation. Request a takedown or correction.

Angry AdvisorsAngry Advisors

We help channel your anger into action. Will we get your money back? Probably not. But we'll make some folks sweat and you'll feel better.

Not a law firm. Angry Advisors is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Nothing here creates an attorney-client relationship. For legal advice, consult a licensed attorney. Find a lawyer (attorney partner network — coming soon).

Every submission requires a truth attestation. We prompt facts and your own experience, not accusations. Takedown / correction requests.

Angry Advisors is a project of GAIN Power. © 2026 GAIN Power, LLC.Terms of UsePrivacy Policyamy@gainpower.org